Comparative cases

Selected cases involving other states, with primary records and questions for applying the same legal framework.

China

The Sino–Vietnamese War, 1979

China and Vietnam presented conflicting accounts of armed incidents and claims of aggression to the Security Council. The Council’s annual report records the parties’ positions and the ensuing debate.

Question for comparison. What evidence establishes the sequence, scale and location of cross-border force, and how does it bear on claims of self-defense?

UN Security Council report, 1978–1979 Vietnam’s letter of 17 February 1979 Related U.S. case

Russia

The invasion of Ukraine, 2022

In Resolution ES-11/1, the UN General Assembly deplored Russia’s aggression against Ukraine and demanded the withdrawal of Russian forces.

Question for comparison. How do the scale of the invasion and the justifications presented to the UN bear on the Charter analysis?

UN General Assembly Resolution ES-11/1

France

The Libya intervention, 2011

France took part in the coalition campaign after the Security Council authorized force to protect civilians under threat and excluded a foreign occupation force.

Question for comparison. How did the purpose and conduct of later operations relate to the civilian-protection mandate?

UN Security Council Resolution 1973 Related U.S. case

Israel

The 1967 invasion and occupation

Israel opened the June 1967 war with strikes on Egypt. During the war it took the Sinai Peninsula, Gaza Strip, West Bank including East Jerusalem, and Golan Heights. Security Council Resolution 242 addressed withdrawal and the inadmissibility of acquiring territory by war. In 2024, the International Court of Justice found Israel’s continued presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory unlawful.

Question for comparison. How does the evidence bear on Israel’s claims of self-defense at the opening of hostilities? What rules govern territorial acquisition and continued occupation?

CIA assessment, 5 June 1967 U.S. State Department, 1967 war chronology UN Security Council Resolution 242 ICJ advisory opinion, 19 July 2024, para. 285 Related U.S. case

United Kingdom

The Iraq invasion, 2003

The Iraq Inquiry documents the United Kingdom’s decision to use force, including its government’s reliance on earlier Security Council resolutions and the process for reaching a legal position.

Question for comparison. What evidence supports the argument that earlier authorization revived, and how should the relevant resolutions be read together?

The Iraq Inquiry, Executive Summary and Volume V Related U.S. case

The comparative cases serve as research benchmarks. The atlas’s map and statistics use the U.S. intervention inventory.