Conduct and chronology
Dates and phases
20 December 1989–31 January 1990: campaign/accounting window used by GAO. Cole’s JCS history dates operational termination to 11 January; Noriega surrendered on 3 January. The 1987–89 sanctions, covert support and military pressure are antecedents. Subsequent Promote Liberty stabilization and later proceedings have separate dates; their deaths are not automatically included. Earlier Canal Zone interventions are excluded. [PA3, pp. 63, 69; PA8, p. 1]
Intervention documented
The United States invaded Panama with aerial bombardment and ground assaults, attacked and dismantled the Panama Defense Forces (PDF), detained and removed Noriega to face U.S. criminal charges, and supported a new civilian government and reconstruction. Earlier U.S. measures included economic sanctions, intelligence/covert political assistance, clandestine broadcasting and contingency planning. Covert findings authorized work with PDF dissidents; they do not establish that Washington directed every coup attempt. [PA4, PA5, PA6, PA7]
Legal assessment
Insufficient evidence to establish a prima facie case of U.S. aggression or assistance to aggression; further investigation may be warranted
U.S. forces invaded Panama; the validity of presidential consent is the decisive issue for the aggression finding. Endara’s electoral victory had been annulled by the Noriega regime; the United States reported consulting him before the landing and obtaining his cooperation. [PA3, pp. 10–11; PA10; PA12, pp. 2–4] Consent could not excuse violations of humanitarian obligations. The IACHR found that U.S. operations violated rights under the American Declaration, applying the humanitarian-law principles of distinction, necessity, proportionality and precaution. Its findings cover civilian death, injury and destruction at El Chorrillo; they do not determine Endara’s authority to consent. [AC1, paras. 281–287, 394–403, 425–431, 471–472; AC2] The humanitarian and human-rights violations are established. The ad bellum question turns on the validity, timing and scope of consent and the other asserted justifications. [PA10; PA12; PL2; PL5]
we won’t get rid of him except by force and pressure
The minutes of a May 1989 National Security Council meeting record Brent Scowcroft’s assessment of how to remove Noriega.
[PA2] White House, Minutes of the NSC Meeting on Panama, 8 May 1989, pp. 4–5, Scowcroft’s description of the consensus; original declassified minutes, National Security Archive reproduction.Human consequences
At least 300 Panamanian civilians died, according to Physicians for Human Rights; Americas Watch estimated about 300 and could not establish a reliable upper bound. [PM1, pp. 3–4, 21–23; PM2, casualty appendix] PHR also estimated 15,000 displaced and at least 3,000 civilians injured seriously enough to require emergency treatment during the invasion and its violent aftermath. [PM1, pp. 3–4] El Chorrillo and other areas suffered destruction, fire and looting. The IACHR established U.S. responsibility for disproportionate civilian-property damage. Its finding does not attribute every act of destruction or establish a comprehensive monetary total. [PM2; AC1, paras. 425–431]
Sources for victim figures
- Panamanian civilian deaths, displacement and emergency treatment
- [PM1] Physicians for Human Rights, Operation “Just Cause”: The Human Cost of Military Action in Panama, October 1991, printed pp. 4, 21–23, summary and casualty methodology
- [PM2] Americas Watch, Panama (1991), “Freedom of Expression, the Right to Assembly, and the Right to Privacy” and appendix “The Issue of Civilian Casualties Revisited”; February 1991 fieldwork and follow-up
Physical destruction
Investigators documented fire and extensive destruction in El Chorrillo, where the Panamanian military headquarters stood in a densely populated neighborhood.
- [PM1] Physicians for Human Rights, Operation “Just Cause”: The Human Cost of Military Action in Panama, October 1991, printed pp. 4, 21–23, summary and casualty methodology
- [PM2] Americas Watch, Panama (1991), “Freedom of Expression, the Right to Assembly, and the Right to Privacy” and appendix “The Issue of Civilian Casualties Revisited”; February 1991 fieldwork and follow-up
- [AC1] IACHR, Report No. 121/18, José Isabel Salas Galindo and Others (United States), 5 October 2018, paras. 281–287, 394–403, 425–431, 471–472. Spanish primary-report reproduction by Panama’s December 20 Commission; human-rights merits findings interpreted in light of humanitarian law.
Economic costs
Cost to U.S. taxpayers
US$163.6 million in incremental DoD costs for Operation Just Cause
The estimate includes preparation and dependent evacuation. It excludes regular military pay and other routine costs. GAO reported the services’ figures.
≈$403M in 2025 USD
The 1990 CPI-U of 130.7 is the workbook’s timing proxy for the 1989–1990 operation.
The taxpayer subtotal covers prima facie findings of aggression or assistance to aggression.
Economic cost to victims
Unquantified
Sources and citation
Documentary and bibliographic references from the research edition.
- [PA1] State Department Policy Planning Staff, “Talking Points for Secretary’s Interview,” drafted 6 December 1988; FRUS 1981–1988, vol. I, doc. 331, p. 1537 and fn. 1
- [PA2] White House, “Minutes of NSC Meeting on Panama,” 8 May 1989, pp. 4–5; Bush Library, NSC H-Files, NSC/DC Meeting Files, folder NSC0015. Declassified original reproduced by National Security Archive
- [PA3] Ronald H. Cole, Operation Just Cause: The Planning and Execution of Joint Operations in Panama, February 1988–January 1990 (Joint History Office, 1995), pp. 10–11, 15–16, 27–30, 35, 51, 63, 65–66, 69
- [PA4] L. Britt Snider, The Agency and the Hill: CIA’s Relationship with Congress, 1946–2004 (CIA Center for the Study of Intelligence, 2008), pp. 299–300. Agency-published historical account; author’s interpretations carry its disclaimer
- [PA5] Lawrence A. Yates, The U.S. Military Intervention in Panama: Origins, Planning, and Crisis Management, June 1987–December 1989 (Army CMH, 2008), pp. 7–20, 157–159
- [PA6] State Department Office of the Historian, “Central America, 1981–1993,” final Panama discussion
- [PA7] U.S. Army Special Operations History Office, “U.S. Army Special Operations Forces (ARSOF) in Panama,” overview
- [PA8] GAO, Panama: Cost of the U.S. Invasion of Panama, GAO/NSIAD-90-279FS, 13 September 1990, pp. 1–2, table 1
Show 18 additional references
- [PA12] GAO, Panama: Issues Relating to the U.S. Invasion, GAO/NSIAD-91-174FS, 24 April 1991, pp. 2–4 (U.S. legal position), p. 6/table 1 (courts-martial)
- [PA13] President Carter, Address to the Nation, 1 February 1978, “Panama Canal Treaties”; FRUS 1977–1980, vol. I, doc. 67, pp. 318–319 (U.S. territorial control, Panamanian discontent and U.S. security objectives)
- [PA14] State Department Office of the Historian, “The Panama Canal and the Torrijos-Carter Treaties,” sections on the 1977 agreements, ratification, 1979 entry into force and 1999 transfer
- [PA15] Jesús Ceberio, “Se descarta que Torrijos muriera víctima de un atentado,” El País, 13 November 1981, opening four paragraphs. Contemporary press account of the Panamanian official inquiry and Moisés Torrijos's CIA allegation; the original inquiry report was not reviewed
- [PA16] United States v. Noriega, 117 F.3d 1206 (11th Cir. 1997), section B, “The CIPA Ruling,” paragraph beginning “In this case, Noriega gave notice…” and following paragraphs. Federal judicial record of the government's offered stipulation concerning approximately $320,000 in combined U.S. Army/CIA payments; reproduced by Justia
- [PM1] Physicians for Human Rights, Operation “Just Cause”: The Human Cost of Military Action in Panama, October 1991, printed pp. 4, 21–23, summary and casualty methodology
- [PM2] Americas Watch, Panama (1991), “Freedom of Expression, the Right to Assembly, and the Right to Privacy” and appendix “The Issue of Civilian Casualties Revisited”; February 1991 fieldwork and follow-up
- [CPI1] BLS, “Summary of annual and semi-annual indexes,” CPI-U U.S. city average, all items, annual 2025=321.943
- [CPI2] Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, “Consumer Price Index, 1913–,” annual 1989=124.0 and 1990=130.7 (BLS series)
- [PL5] UN General Assembly Resolution 44/240, “Effects of the Military Intervention by the United States of America in Panama,” 29 December 1989, operative paras. 1–2.
- [PA9] George H. W. Bush, “Address to the Nation Announcing United States Military Action in Panama,” 20 December 1989, opening and objectives paragraphs; Bush Presidential Library
- [PA10] Bush, “Letter to the Speaker of the House of Representatives and the President Pro Tempore of the Senate on United States Military Action in Panama,” 21 December 1989 (released 22 December), deployment, government-formation and legal-basis paragraphs
- [AC1] Inter-Am. Comm’n H.R., Report No. 121/18, Case 10.573, José Isabel Salas Galindo and Others (United States), OEA/Ser.L/V/II.169, Doc. 138, ¶¶ 281–87, 394–403, 425–31, 471–72 (Oct. 5, 2018). Human-rights merits findings interpreted in light of humanitarian law; not an aggression judgment.
- [PL2] Thomas R. Pickering, U.S. letter to the President of the Security Council, S/21035, 20 December 1989, paras. 1–3
- [PL6] UN Security Council draft S/21048, vote at meeting S/PV.2902, 23 December 1989; UN voting record
- [AC1] IACHR, Report No. 121/18, José Isabel Salas Galindo and Others (United States), 5 October 2018, paras. 281–287, 394–403, 425–431, 471–472. Spanish primary-report reproduction by Panama’s December 20 Commission; human-rights merits findings interpreted in light of humanitarian law.
- [AC2] IACHR, Press Release 258/18, IACHR Publishes Report No. 121/18, Case 10.573—José Isabel Salas Galindo and Others, Concerning the United States, 3 December 2018. Official summary of findings, recommendations and U.S. response; no aggression determination.
- [PA2] White House, Minutes of the NSC Meeting on Panama, 8 May 1989, pp. 4–5, Scowcroft’s description of the consensus; original declassified minutes, National Security Archive reproduction.
Restrepo, Ricardo. The Atlas of U.S. International Aggression: A Historical and Legal Assessment of U.S. Uses of Force. Working research edition, 10 November 2026. Case PAN-1989-90-01.
Panama